Alliance for Affordable Energy
  • Home
  • Who
  • What
    • Consumer Protection and Education >
      • Regulate Our Pipelines
      • Health Impact Assessment
    • Clean Energy >
      • Renewable & Clean Portfolio Standard
      • Transmission
    • Energy Efficiency >
      • EEFA
    • GS4GND
    • Past Work
  • How
    • New Orleans City Council >
      • Council Actions
    • New Orleans Dockets >
      • UD-22-05 Hurricane Ida Costs
      • UD-22-04 Demand Solutions
      • UD-22-03 Battery Storage
      • UD-22-02 100% Renewable
      • UD-22-01 Storm Reserve
      • UD-21-03 Resilience
      • UD-21-02 Zeta Cost Recovery
      • UD-21-01 Winter Storm Uri
      • UD-20-02 IRP (2021)
      • UD-19-01 RPS
      • UD-18-07 ENO Rate Case
      • UD-18-02 EV Charging
      • UD-18-01 Smart Cities
      • UD-17-04 Reliability
      • UD-17-03 IRP (2018)
    • LA Public Service Commission >
      • LPSC 2022 Election
      • Engage with the LPSC
    • Lawsuits & Appeals
    • Climate Initiative Task Force
  • News
    • The Watchdog
    • People's Power Hour
    • MISO Soup
    • Hurricane Ida
    • Events Calendar >
      • AAE House Party
  • Learn
    • Glossary
    • Timeline
    • Reports
  • Get Involved
    • Support
    • Newsletter
    • Intern and Volunteer >
      • Wimpelberg Intern Fellowship
    • Contact Us

The Watchdog

A blog on energy matters in Louisiana!

Electric Companies Like Entergy Are Using Affiliate Transactions to Block Renewable Energy, Here’s How

12/12/2019

3 Comments

 
Picture
Despite the environmental, economic, and reliability benefits of switching to  a renewables future, New Orleans, Louisiana is being blocked by local utility monopoly, Entergy.

BY: JOSEPH DANIEL, SENIOR ENERGY ANALYST 
Published by Union of Concerned Scientists
December 11, 2019, 12:38 PM EST

NOLA is ready to embrace an all-renewables future. Why? Well, UCS research shows that making the switch would probably
 save them money. Plus, renewables are more reliable than many of their current sources of electricity. There is only one thing in their way: the local monopoly utility, Entergy New Orleans (ENO).
​

The king of affiliate transactions


​Entergy New Orleans (ENO) is owned by Entergy. Entergy owns a lot of utilities including rate-regulated utilities like Entergy Arkansas and Entergy Louisiana; as well merchant utilities like System Energy Resources Inc (ESRI). ESRI only owns a single power plant, Grand Gulf Nuclear Power Station, which is a notoriously unreliable reactor that has suffered numerous safety and operational issues in the past.

Each of those other companies—also owned by Entergy—are considered affiliated companies. Entergy often has these affiliated companies enter into agreements to buy/sell electricity. And that is an affiliate transaction.

While affiliate transactions certainly aren’t uncommon, Entergy is the king of affiliate transactions between electric affiliates.

Affiliate transactions might not be inherently bad for customers, but they don’t have a great track record of providing consumer benefits. In fact, both electric-electric and gas-electric affiliate transactions have recently come under scrutiny.

I recently went over all the reported affiliate transactions associated with the sale of electricity in 2018. There were some $5 billion dollars in wholesale electric transactions between affiliated companies. But more so than the $5 billion, something else stood out:
​
20% of all affiliate transactions in 2018 were associated with Entergy affiliates.
​

Picture
Map of service territories of utilities. Map Rendered using S&P Global Software.
Picture
Entergy isn’t the only utility that relies on affiliate transactions. UCS analysis of S&P Global data.
Entergy is now using those affiliate transactions to block the development of renewable energy.
​

Blocking a push for local renewables 


​Entergy has an established history of using untoward tactics to get customers to pay for questionable investment decisions. Most recently, they engaged in an Astroturf campaign (a fake grassroots campaign) wherein they hired paid actors to feign support for a gas-fired plant that local advocates overwhelming opposed.

Eventually, the New Orleans City Council opted to hear from the public on passing a mandate that a percentage of electricity be generated from renewable sources (like wind and solar).

The vast majority of comments supported a pathway to a 100% renewable electricity standard (RES) with some opting for a 100% clean electricity standard (CES). The latter leaves the door open for technologies like carbon capture sequestration and/or nuclear.

Entergy had a different idea. They proposed a 70% CES: A lifeline to their struggling nuclear power plants. You see, Entergy affiliates already provide Entergy New Orleans with upwards of 57% of their annual energy from nuclear generation (though it tends to be much lower due to outages at Grand Gulf Nuclear Plant). They also appear to be providing Entergy with a very high rate of return.

Entergy’s existing resources, plus a 150MW of new renewables, would get ENO to (or very nearly to) the 70% target. Plus, it would protect any new gas plants they have from the risk of becoming stranded assets.

Earlier this year, UCS helped do some research and analysis for a group of advocates in New Orleans that were pushing for a 100% Resilient Renewable Portfolio Standard. UCS’s research showed that by switching to 100% renewables and efficiency, the city’s residents could likely see lower bills.

UCS even filed a letter in support of a 100% RES for New Orleans.
​
Entergy did not like that and claimed that coalition (including UCS) was engaging in the intellectual equivalent of climate denial. To suggest that the Union of Concerned Scientists is engaging in the intellectual equivalence of climate denial is the act of a desperate corporation.
​

​Hiding behind FERC


​Equating UCS to climate deniers wasn’t the only desperate measure Entergy has taken. They have begun threatening the city council and advocates.

Entergy also attempted to hide behind FERC approval for affiliate transactions as a barrier to build the 100% RPS future NOLA deserves.

Through a couple of different subsidiaries, Entergy owns two coal plants and a nuclear power plant that sell electricity–at wholesale–to various utilities, including ENO. Wholesale transactions are regulated exclusively by FERC.

The transactions between the nuclear plant (Grand Gulf) have a long and dramatic history, dating back to the 1980’s. The transactions were heavily litigated and those litigations even went up to the Supreme Court. Entergy renewed a contract to provide service on the business as usual operations. Both the Louisiana PSC and the Arkansas PSC have pending complaints against Grand Gulf, arguing that it is overcharging for its service.

Entergy is now saying that ENO is obligated to buy electricity from Entergy-owned Grand Gulf, and therefore can’t possibly buy 100% of its electricity from renewables. Plus, Entergy claims that ENO customers are on the hook for any investments that the utility makes into Grand Gulf, with no oversight onto the prudencey or reasonableness of those investments.

Regardless of the squabbles at the wholesale level, my main point is that state and local regulators still have an oversight role. There are a number of questions that seem to fall squarely in local jurisdictions.

One obvious question: Is the recent contract renewal “imprudent” for consumers? Given other favorable options available to the utility, maybe it was.

Another question, are these types of affiliate transactions producing a rate of return for Entergy that is above the allowed rate of return permitted by state and local utility commissions?

I’m not specifically asserting that one or both of these questions is yes. To find the answer one would almost certainly have to litigate the question at the commission or at the courts.

Entergy would have the city council and the people of New Orleans believe that this is a black or white issue. That simply isn’t true. This simply isn’t the clear-cut case Entergy wants you to think it is. Entergy is trying to bully its way into getting what it wants.
​
I’d also add that there is another way for the contract to be broken or at least renegotiated. Entergy, because it owns both ENO and SEPI, could simply elect to do it. The counterparties of the contract are fully capable of renegotiating terms on their own. So, it isn’t like Entergy can’t do anything about it—in fact, the easiest solution is one they can implement alone.
​

​NOLA has to act now


​UCS’s 2018 nuclear power analysis showed that Grand Gulf is uncompetitive compared to the market, and if retired, would likely be replaced by fossil fuels, but that didn’t account for the 100% RES that is being considered by the city of New Orleans. UCS’s report also explicitly acknowledges that with sufficient planning and strong climate and clean energy policies, we can make a smooth transition to clean energy. If New Orleans makes a strong commitment to ramp-up renewables, today, it could avoid investing in natural gas plants and avoid doubling down on Grand Gulf, all while reducing emissions and saving consumers money.

​It seems to me that New Orleans could be in an abusive relationship with its utility. Their dynamic is about power and control, and Entergy is trying to use its power to make NOLA feel powerless, to feel like it has no control even though the city has every right to direct its clean electricity future.
​
The people of the city of New Orleans and the elected officials are the ones with the power over its power. They can—and will—take control of that future and take tangible action to address climate change, which threatens the lives and livelihoods of everyone in the city.

View original article published by Union of Concerned Scientists

3 Comments

Kristofer Van Wagner link
6/10/2020 10:09:39 pm

Thank you for sharing these useful information on energy oversight. My brother the other day asked about utility oversight services. I think I will share with him this article, so that he will have a better understanding.

Reply
laptop repair dubai link
8/25/2020 11:50:38 pm

We know that solar power would be run laptop . But sometimes technical issue would be occur with laptop and at that time problem would be solve through laptop repair service center.

Reply
Laptop service center Dubai link
1/6/2022 03:48:07 am

Thanks for sharing this informative article

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    RSS Feed

    Archives

    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    October 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    October 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    May 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    December 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    January 2014
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012

    Categories

    All
    Alexandria Lia
    ALI
    ALI Meiner
    Andrew Wiseman
    Anniversary
    Bia Assevero
    CalGreen
    CCS
    Charles Rice
    Clean Energy
    CLECO
    CLECO FAQ
    CLECO Sale
    CLECO Sale Denied
    CLECO Stock
    CLECO Stock Prices
    CLECO Takeover
    Climate Change
    Clyde Holloway
    CO2
    Coastal Restoration
    Corruption
    Cost
    David Roberts
    Decoupling
    Dirty Energy
    Education
    Elections
    Energy
    Energy Efficiency
    Energy Policy
    Energy Smart
    Entergy
    Entergy New Orleans
    Environmental Risks
    EPA
    FERC
    Gas Plant
    Georgetown
    Government
    Grand Gulf
    Green Building
    Grid Failure
    GSREIA
    Gulf Of Mexico
    Health Risks
    Hurricane
    Hurricane Sandy
    Industrials
    Infrastructure
    IRP
    Land Loss
    Land-Use
    LA Public Service Commission
    LEED
    Liquid Air
    Louisiana
    Louisiana Public Service Commission
    LPSC
    MACQUAIRE
    Mayor's Office
    MISO
    Natural Gas
    New Iberia
    New Orleans City Council
    News
    NRDC
    Nuclear
    Oil & Gas Leases
    People Power
    Pipelines
    Power Grid
    Power Outages
    Power Plant
    Public Interest
    Regulation
    Reliability
    Renewable Energy
    RENEWABLE ENERGY POLICY NETWORK FOR THE 21ST CENTURY
    Resiliency
    Resolutions
    RTO
    Rulemaking
    Sacrifice Zones
    Sea Level Rise
    Solar
    Storage Solutions
    Subsidies
    SWEPCO
    TED Talks
    The Town Walk
    Town Hall Meetings
    Transmission
    Utilities
    Vicki Arroyo
    Watchdog
    Water Conservation
    Water Use
    WDSU
    Wetlands
    WWL Radio

    RSS Feed

Intern & Volunteer
If you want to be a frontline soldier on environmental protection, social justice, or environmental racism, come to Louisiana” –Gary Groesch, Founder of AAE
Calendar
View our events calendar ​for important upcoming community events and public meetings!
Support our work- ensure fair, affordable, and environmentally responsible energy for all.
501(c)3 IRS Notice

Alliance for Affordable Energy
Phone: (504) 208-9761
4505 S Claiborne Ave
New Orleans, LA 70175

Copyright © 2022 · Alliance for Affordable Energy
  • Home
  • Who
  • What
    • Consumer Protection and Education >
      • Regulate Our Pipelines
      • Health Impact Assessment
    • Clean Energy >
      • Renewable & Clean Portfolio Standard
      • Transmission
    • Energy Efficiency >
      • EEFA
    • GS4GND
    • Past Work
  • How
    • New Orleans City Council >
      • Council Actions
    • New Orleans Dockets >
      • UD-22-05 Hurricane Ida Costs
      • UD-22-04 Demand Solutions
      • UD-22-03 Battery Storage
      • UD-22-02 100% Renewable
      • UD-22-01 Storm Reserve
      • UD-21-03 Resilience
      • UD-21-02 Zeta Cost Recovery
      • UD-21-01 Winter Storm Uri
      • UD-20-02 IRP (2021)
      • UD-19-01 RPS
      • UD-18-07 ENO Rate Case
      • UD-18-02 EV Charging
      • UD-18-01 Smart Cities
      • UD-17-04 Reliability
      • UD-17-03 IRP (2018)
    • LA Public Service Commission >
      • LPSC 2022 Election
      • Engage with the LPSC
    • Lawsuits & Appeals
    • Climate Initiative Task Force
  • News
    • The Watchdog
    • People's Power Hour
    • MISO Soup
    • Hurricane Ida
    • Events Calendar >
      • AAE House Party
  • Learn
    • Glossary
    • Timeline
    • Reports
  • Get Involved
    • Support
    • Newsletter
    • Intern and Volunteer >
      • Wimpelberg Intern Fellowship
    • Contact Us