Alliance for Affordable Energy
  • Home
  • Who
  • What
    • Consumer Protection and Education >
      • Regulate Our Pipelines
      • Health Impact Assessment
    • Clean Energy >
      • Renewable & Clean Portfolio Standard
      • Transmission
    • Energy Efficiency >
      • EEFA
    • GS4GND
    • Past Work
  • How
    • New Orleans City Council >
      • Council Actions
    • New Orleans Dockets >
      • UD-22-05 Hurricane Ida Costs
      • UD-22-04 Demand Solutions
      • UD-22-03 Battery Storage
      • UD-22-02 100% Renewable
      • UD-22-01 Storm Reserve
      • UD-21-03 Resilience
      • UD-21-02 Zeta Cost Recovery
      • UD-21-01 Winter Storm Uri
      • UD-20-02 IRP (2021)
      • UD-19-01 RPS
      • UD-18-07 ENO Rate Case
      • UD-18-02 EV Charging
      • UD-18-01 Smart Cities
      • UD-17-04 Reliability
      • UD-17-03 IRP (2018)
    • LA Public Service Commission >
      • LPSC 2022 Election
      • Engage with the LPSC
    • Lawsuits & Appeals
    • Climate Initiative Task Force
  • News
    • The Watchdog
    • People's Power Hour
    • MISO Soup
    • Hurricane Ida
    • Events Calendar >
      • AAE House Party
  • Learn
    • Glossary
    • Timeline
    • Reports
  • Get Involved
    • Support
    • Newsletter
    • Intern and Volunteer >
      • Wimpelberg Intern Fellowship
    • Contact Us

The Watchdog

A blog on energy matters in Louisiana!

City Council goes before state appeals court seeking to overturn ruling against Entergy plant by MICHAEL ISAAC STEIN

1/6/2020

0 Comments

 
By MICHAEL ISAAC STEIN
​
Article originally published by The Lens
JANUARY 6, 2020
Picture
A colorful protest against Entergy's gas plant in eastern New Orleans, held in front of the Fourth District Court of Appeals. (Michael Isaac Stein/The Lens)
The New Orleans City Council went to state appeals court on Monday in an attempt to reverse a June ruling in Civil District Court that voided the 2018 vote approving Entergy New Orleans’ controversial power plant in eastern New Orleans. ​​
In the June ruling, Judge Piper Griffin found that Louisiana’s Open Meetings Law was “undermined” because one of Entergy’s subcontractors hired actors to show up early to a public meeting on the plant, while unpaid residents were unable to get in because the room was at capacity. 

The City Council appealed that decision to the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeal, and on Monday, a panel of three judges — Judge James McKay, Judge Paula Brown and Judge Dale Atkins — listened to oral arguments from the City Council, Entergy New Orleans and the coalition of environmental and consumer advocates that filed the original lawsuit against the council. 

There has been some tension between Entergy and the City Council in recent weeks. The utility launched two lawsuits against the council in December over votes setting utility rates and imposing a $1 million fine against the company. But on Monday, Entergy and the council were sitting on the same side of the table. Though Entergy was not a named defendant in the original suit, the company has intervened in the case and is paying for outside, private attorneys to represent the City Council, according to an August council motion. 

The council’s private attorney, James Garner, stressed two arguments for why the appeals court should reverse the lower courts’ ruling. First, he pointed out that in the lower court ruling, the judge said that the council “did nothing wrong.” Instead, the judge placed the blame on Entergy for its involvement in the paid actor scandal. Garner argued that there could not be an Open Meetings Law violation as the result of actions taken by a private company.

Second, he argued that the meeting at which the violation occurred didn’t actually matter. The February 2018 meeting was a utility committee meeting, not a full City Council meeting. During the February meeting, the committee voted in favor of recommending approval for the power plant and moved the issue to the full council. The full council gave the final thumbs up for the plant at a March 2018 meeting. 

“The meeting wasn’t required, wasn’t necessary,” Garner argued on Monday. “The only meeting that counted was the March 8 meeting.”

Some found that to be an unsettling argument to come from the City Council, including a former council member who was named as a defendant in the suit. Susan Guidry, who left the council in 2018, a few months after the March vote, was the sole council member to vote against the plant at the February and March meetings. She attended Monday’s hearing. 

“To say our committee votes are irrelevant, it’s shocking to hear that from a city council lawyer,” she told The Lens after the hearing.

The panel of judges also heard arguments on a second lawsuit filed by a similar coalition that, like the first suit, called into question the legitimacy of the council’s decision to approve the gas plant. Griffin ruled in favor of the city in that suit. On Monday, the council argued that ruling should be upheld. 

The judges will likely issue rulings in the coming weeks or months. 
​

‘Paid citizens have the same right to attend public meetings’


​As The Lens first reported in March 2018, and as the City Council later confirmed with its own investigation, one of Entergy’s subcontractors hired dozens of people, including some professional actors, to go to two City Council meetings and support the plant. One of those was the February 2018 utility committee meeting. 

At the time, the City Council chamber was under construction, so the meeting was held at a smaller auditorium at the Pan American Life Building. The day before the meeting, an Entergy executive sent an email to several other employees.

“I received confirmation that the room will open at 8:30 am,” the email said. “Let’s get as many of our folks there ahead of the bus from NO East.”

That email was forwarded to the man who organized the hired plant supporters, who then agreed to get them to the auditorium at 8 a.m., two hours before the meeting began. The email was likely referencing two buses organized by the nonprofit VAYLA New Orleans to transport concerned residents of eastern New Orleans to the meeting. VAYLA is part of the coalition suing the council. 

The buses from eastern New Orleans arrived at 9:20 am, 40 minutes before the meeting began, according to a court filing from the plaintiffs. The filing claims that the 67 residents that came on the buses, largely made up of residents of eastern New Orleans, were informed that the auditorium was full and that they couldn’t enter. 

Some of those residents would later be let into the meeting or allowed to fill out comment cards.

The Louisiana Open Meetings law requires all meetings of public bodies to be open to members of the public. There are some exceptions to the law, such as executive sessions to discuss ongoing litigation. However, the council has not argued that any exception applied to the February meeting. Instead, they argued that “the District Court’s ruling was premised on private conduct—conduct beyond the control of the City Council.” 

Several people, including resident Danil Faust, warned the council that people were being paid to attend meetings prior to and during the February meeting. 

“It is not the duty of government to establish acceptable grounds for citizens to attend public meetings and speak on matters of public consequence,” the council’s written filing said. “Indeed, paid citizens have the same right to attend public meetings as unpaid citizens.”

The attorney for the plaintiffs, Susan Stevens Miller, argued that whatever the reason the room filled to capacity, it was the responsibility of the council to ensure that the public could participate in the meeting. 

“The utility committee absolutely lost control of its meeting,” she argued on Monday. She said that her clients’ rights were violated regardless of whether the council intentionally and knowingly did something wrong. 

She also pushed back against the council’s assertion that the February vote was meaningless. 

“It’s the process, not the result, that matters when it comes to the Open Meetings Law,” she said. She reminded the panel of judges that they were not asking the court to shut down Entergy’s power plant. Instead, she said, the plaintiffs were only asking for a decision making process that adhered to the Open Meetings Law. 

After that, Miller said, the council could make any decision it wanted, even if that decision is to once again approve the plant. 
View Original Article

MICHAEL ISAAC STEIN
​Michael Isaac Stein covers New Orleans' cultural economy and local government for The Lens. Before joining the staff, he freelanced for The Lens as well as The Intercept, CityLab, The New Republic, and... More by Michael Isaac Stein
0 Comments




Leave a Reply.

    RSS Feed

    Archives

    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    October 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    October 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    May 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    December 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    January 2014
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012

    Categories

    All
    Alexandria Lia
    ALI
    ALI Meiner
    Andrew Wiseman
    Anniversary
    Bia Assevero
    CalGreen
    CCS
    Charles Rice
    Clean Energy
    CLECO
    CLECO FAQ
    CLECO Sale
    CLECO Sale Denied
    CLECO Stock
    CLECO Stock Prices
    CLECO Takeover
    Climate Change
    Clyde Holloway
    CO2
    Coastal Restoration
    Corruption
    Cost
    David Roberts
    Decoupling
    Dirty Energy
    Education
    Elections
    Energy
    Energy Efficiency
    Energy Policy
    Energy Smart
    Entergy
    Entergy New Orleans
    Environmental Risks
    EPA
    FERC
    Gas Plant
    Georgetown
    Government
    Grand Gulf
    Green Building
    Grid Failure
    GSREIA
    Gulf Of Mexico
    Health Risks
    Hurricane
    Hurricane Sandy
    Industrials
    Infrastructure
    IRP
    Land Loss
    Land-Use
    LA Public Service Commission
    LEED
    Liquid Air
    Louisiana
    Louisiana Public Service Commission
    LPSC
    MACQUAIRE
    Mayor's Office
    MISO
    Natural Gas
    New Iberia
    New Orleans City Council
    News
    NRDC
    Nuclear
    Oil & Gas Leases
    People Power
    Pipelines
    Power Grid
    Power Outages
    Power Plant
    Public Interest
    Regulation
    Reliability
    Renewable Energy
    RENEWABLE ENERGY POLICY NETWORK FOR THE 21ST CENTURY
    Resiliency
    Resolutions
    RTO
    Rulemaking
    Sacrifice Zones
    Sea Level Rise
    Solar
    Storage Solutions
    Subsidies
    SWEPCO
    TED Talks
    The Town Walk
    Town Hall Meetings
    Transmission
    Utilities
    Vicki Arroyo
    Watchdog
    Water Conservation
    Water Use
    WDSU
    Wetlands
    WWL Radio

    RSS Feed

Intern & Volunteer
If you want to be a frontline soldier on environmental protection, social justice, or environmental racism, come to Louisiana” –Gary Groesch, Founder of AAE
Calendar
View our events calendar ​for important upcoming community events and public meetings!
Support our work- ensure fair, affordable, and environmentally responsible energy for all.
501(c)3 IRS Notice

Alliance for Affordable Energy
Phone: (504) 208-9761
4505 S Claiborne Ave
New Orleans, LA 70175

Copyright © 2022 · Alliance for Affordable Energy
  • Home
  • Who
  • What
    • Consumer Protection and Education >
      • Regulate Our Pipelines
      • Health Impact Assessment
    • Clean Energy >
      • Renewable & Clean Portfolio Standard
      • Transmission
    • Energy Efficiency >
      • EEFA
    • GS4GND
    • Past Work
  • How
    • New Orleans City Council >
      • Council Actions
    • New Orleans Dockets >
      • UD-22-05 Hurricane Ida Costs
      • UD-22-04 Demand Solutions
      • UD-22-03 Battery Storage
      • UD-22-02 100% Renewable
      • UD-22-01 Storm Reserve
      • UD-21-03 Resilience
      • UD-21-02 Zeta Cost Recovery
      • UD-21-01 Winter Storm Uri
      • UD-20-02 IRP (2021)
      • UD-19-01 RPS
      • UD-18-07 ENO Rate Case
      • UD-18-02 EV Charging
      • UD-18-01 Smart Cities
      • UD-17-04 Reliability
      • UD-17-03 IRP (2018)
    • LA Public Service Commission >
      • LPSC 2022 Election
      • Engage with the LPSC
    • Lawsuits & Appeals
    • Climate Initiative Task Force
  • News
    • The Watchdog
    • People's Power Hour
    • MISO Soup
    • Hurricane Ida
    • Events Calendar >
      • AAE House Party
  • Learn
    • Glossary
    • Timeline
    • Reports
  • Get Involved
    • Support
    • Newsletter
    • Intern and Volunteer >
      • Wimpelberg Intern Fellowship
    • Contact Us